Clevercactus Share
Tuesday, March 30th, 2004Russell Beattie “reviews”:http://www.russellbeattie.com/notebook/1007167.html “Clevercactus Share”:http://www.clevercactus.com/.
Most of Russell’s issues with the application are to do with its use of Swing. I am still undecided about Swing–it is certainly possible to create a dog of a UI with any technology. Redrawing issues are problematic for a lot of systems. And this is still a beta product, and it’s extremely usable. Redrawing can be a bit slow at the moment when redisplaying the full window if it was hidden. See the comment on it being beta. Other people know far more than me about the ins and outs of Swing programming–I’ll leave it to them to discuss what’s possible or not.
To get away from that issue, what I’ve seen so far looks great! It is obvious how to use the program, it seems very easy to use. P2P sharing and chat. In work, we’ve vaguely considered a replacement for Yahoo IM, because it’s a centralised point that all our messages go through, with all the attendant privacy issues, etc. As a P2P app, this should run around that (though it still needs a central server for some parts of its operation). The only other reasonable option in the past for chat has been a Jabber server. People aren’t interested in IRC (in general)–and why oh why are some people (yes, you!) using ICB??
I think if it works like it looks, I will push at least for a beta test, see how people like it.
I may post another review once I actually get to chat or share files with somebody–my only contact at the moment may have problems with his service provider dropping/blocking UDP packets. Yes, you need UDP access to the Internet, but otherwise it should work from behind firewalls, even where both users are on private networks behind a NAT proxy.